Providence Day’s Blane McElroy and Pine Lake Prep’s Sadie Peterson led their teams to N.C. girls’ soccer championships this season. Today, they share The Charlotte Observer player of the year honors for 2025.
The All-Observer team represents the top players in the media company’s coverage area, which includes N.C. High School Athletic Association public schools and N.C. Independent Athletic Association private schools in Mecklenburg, Cabarrus, Gaston, Iredell, Lincoln and Union counties.
▪ McElroy — the 2024 N.C. Soccer Coaches and 2024 N.C. Gatorade player of the year — helped Providence Day win its fifth NCISAA 4A state championship in the last six years this spring.
A Princeton commit, McElroy scored 16 goals and had 21 assists while facing constant double-teams this season. She was named all-state and an All-American. The CISAA conference player of the year, McElroy led Providence Day to a 22-2-1 record as the Chargers ended the season ranked No. 1 in North Carolina by MaxPreps and No. 7 in America.
▪ Peterson, a junior forward committed to Clemson, had a school-record 54 goals plus 25 assists and led the Pride to the NCHSAA 2A state championship.
Peterson was named all-state, All-American and was the Catawba Shores 1A/2A player of the year. The N.C. Soccer Coaches Association named her state player of the year. Peterson returned to Pine Lake Prep after attending IMG Academy in Florida last season. Peterson helped the Pride (21-2) finish No. 2 in the state and No. 9 in the nation, according to MaxPreps. ▪ Ardrey Kell’s Kim Montgomery is the coach of the year for the second time in three seasons, after leading the Knights to their second NCHSAA 4A state championship in three years.
Montgomery’s team is used to being the favorite, but entered the 2025 4A state playoffs as the No. 12 overall seed after finishing third in the SoMECK 4A conference. However, Ardrey Kell won its last 13 games, powered by a defense that allowed only seven goals in the run. The Knights finished 23-3-4 this season.
All-Observer first team
FORWARDS
- Amaya Falzarano, Myers Park, Jr.: The Mustangs’ all-state junior forward scored 33 goals and had nine assists this season.
- Elise Larimer, Hough, Sr.: The Huskies’ all-state senior forward, a UNC Wilmington commit, scored 16 goals and had 20 assists this season.
- Dempsey McMahon, Charlotte Latin, Jr.: The Hawks’ all-state junior forward and University of South Carolina commit had 21 goals and 29 assists.
- Jordyn Miller, Charlotte Catholic, Sr.: The Cougars’ all-state forward, a Tufts commit, had 22 goals, four assists and was co-Southwestern 4A player of the year.
- Sadie Peterson, Pine Lake Prep, Jr.: The Pride’s all-state junior was named N.C. Coaches’ Association state player of the year. The Clemson commit had 54 goals, 25 assists.
MIDFIELDERS
- Avery Garrett, Pine Lake Prep, Sr.: The Pride’s all-state senior midfielder, a Campbell University commit, had 33 goals and 41 assists this season. Garrett finished her career as the school’s all-time leading goals, assists and points producer.
- Julia Grier, South Mecklenburg, Sr.: The Sabres’ senior, an all-state pick and Wofford College commit, led South Mecklenburg with 23 goals, nine assists. Grier was SoMeck 4A conference player of the year.
- Blane McElroy, Providence Day, Sr.: The Chargers’ all-state pick, a Princeton commit, was CISAA conference player of the year. She scored 16 goals, had 21 assists, and led Providence Day to its second straight NCISAA 4A state title.
- Ellie Riechman, Ardrey Kell, Sr.: The Knights’ all-state senior scored 18 goals, had 15 assists, and was the 4A state championship’s game’s most valuable player. Riechman, who has a 4.5 grade-point average, will attend the University of Colorado Boulder to study medicine.
- Kate Robinson, Lake Norman Charter, Sr.: The Knights’ all-state senior, a Catawba College commit, was South Piedmont conference player of the year and had 16 goals and 32 assists this season.
MIDFIELD/DEFENDERS
- Morgan Child, Charlotte Catholic, Sr.: The Cougars’ all-state defender also had three goals and four assists to help the offense.
- Abby Goldean, Providence Day, Jr.: The Chargers’ all-state defender also contributed 10 goals and seven assists. Goldean is a major Division I recruit, according to Providence Day coach Dan Dudley.
DEFENDERS
- Sadie Badgett, East Lincoln, Sr.: The Mustangs’ all-state senior center back, a Campbell University commit, led the East Lincoln defense to a school-record 17 shutouts. She scored 10 goals, had 11 assists and helped her team to its first 20-plus win season (21-3-3) in program history.
- Rylan Breath, Mountain Island Charter, Jr.: The Raptors’ all-state junior center back led a defense that had five shutouts in six playoff wins, allowing just one goal in that span. She also had 10 goals and six assists this season.
- Taylor Kleinschmidt, Ardrey Kell, Jr.: The Knights’ all-state center back led a defense that allowed just seven goals in the last 13 games, including just four scores in six playoff games this season. She is a major Division I recruit, according to Montgomery.
- Grace Maynard, South Point, Sr.: The Red Raiders’ all-state center back, a UNC Wilmington commit, was the Big South 3A conference defense player of the year. She scored two goals and had four assists for the 3A state runner-up team.
- Emma Milliron, Hickory Ridge, Sr.: The Ragin’ Bulls’ all-state senior center back, a Winthrop University commit, led the Hickory Ridge defense to 15 shutouts. She also scored five goals, had three assists and was named Greater Metro 4A conference player of the year.
GOALKEEPERS
- Riley Pickels, Hough, Jr.: The Huskies’ junior all-state goalkeeper, a N.C. State commit, had 100 saves, 21 shutouts and allowed only five goals all season. Pickels was QCAC goalkeeper of the year.
- Isabel Seifert, Davidson Day, Sr.: The Patriots’ four-time all-state senior goalkeeper is a University of Richmond commit. This season, she had eight shutouts and allowed only four goals. Seifert helped lead Davidson Day to its third straight NCISAA 3A state title. She also scored four goals and had seven assists.
All-Observer second team
FORWARDS
- Lucy Chin, Marvin Ridge, So.
- Madison Detenber, Providence, Sr.
- Cheyenne Painter, Mountain Island Charter, Jr.
- Kipenzi Perry, Davidson Day, Jr.
- Makayla Rodriguez, Ardrey Kell, So.
- Lia Zimmer, Providence Day, Sr.
FORWARD/MIDFIELDERS
- Caroline Mercuri, Lake Norman Charter, Jr.
- Megan Story, Northwest Cabarrus, Jr.
MIDFIELDERS
- Molly Brown, Charlotte Country Day, Jr.
- Harmoni Carter, Mountain Island Charter, Jr.
- Lucy Grow, Carmel Christian, So.
- Abbi Hoover, Weddington, Jr.
- Claire Zhang, Charlotte Latin, Jr.
DEFENDERS
- Addie Hull, Charlotte Latin, Sr.
- Millie Jones, Covenant Day, Sr.
- Karsyn Lowman, South Point, Jr.
- Jessica Mattson, Marvin Ridge, Sr.
- Isabella Stafford, Lake Norman Charter, Sr.
GOALKEEPERS
- Molly Estes, Marvin Ridge, Sr.
- Isabella Goodwin, South Point, Jr.